Analysis of Mobile Phone Wiki using de Bono’s hats ~
To thoroughly analyse the effectiveness of the Mobile Phone Wiki as a learning tool, I will conduct a Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats (SWOT) analysis on the wiki. I will then explain how this activity links to learning theory and how this type of activity would contribute to learning in a classroom. I will then conduct a personal reflection on the mobile phone hat wiki discussing the benefits and drawbacks of this activity.
Wikis are a base for student-centered learning. Below I have conducted a Strengths, Weakness, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) Analysis of the learning potential of wikis in a classroom situation.
Strengths:
A main strength of a wiki is it creates a constructivist environment (Vygotsky, 1962). It could be suggested that when students learn from each other, they learn most effectively. Students can also encourage each other which can then evoke creativity and a deepening of knowledge and understanding through communication with each other.
Weakness:
A main concern or weakness with a wiki is the ability for students to delete, edit or change other students' work. To minimise this, I would suggest the class put together a wiki mission statement and create a set of rules that reflect ethical and sensible behaviour in online learning environments. Another key weakness with a wiki is that only one person can edit the wiki at any one time. To combat this within a classroom environment I would allocate times for students to enter their information.
Opportunities:
The opportunities for learning within a wiki are many and varied. Wikis can be embedded with video links, links to other websites and provide a wealth of information for collaborative learning. The use of wikis in classrooms could prove to be an effective pedagogy.
Threats
The student wiki would need to be monitored very closely. I would suggest this wiki only be available on the school intranet with a class login to minimise attempts for outside citizens to change or edit information without authorisation. Another threat to classroom wikis is the potential for bullying to take place. Again, I would suggest the class create their own rules and mission statements in line with the ethical guidelines from Education Queensland (2002)
THEORETICAL REFLECTION
Collaborative Learning
The mobile phone wiki using de Bono’s hats could be linked to one learning concept and two main learning theories. The key learning concept of collaborative learning was evident in this activity. Collaborative learning is the process of learning through class or group participation (Simens, 2005). According to the University of Melbourne, collaborative learning is an effective way to teach yourself through teaching others. Through the sharing of ideas, knowledge is deepened and understanding is strengthened (University of Melbourne).
Constructivism and Connectivism
The Mobile Phone Wiki was a perfect example of two main learning theories. These were the learning theory constructivism; and the learning theory connectivism. Vygotsky (1962) in Siemens, (2005) and Bruner (1966) in Lim (2010)are both constructivist theorists and they suggested learning is most effective when students construct their own view of the topics studied (Meggel, 1998) . Futhermore, Vygotsky (1962) and Bruner (1966) suggested constructivism emphasises two main principles these being:
1) Application of prior knowledge
2) Learning is a quest for meaning
However the Wiki also represents what Siemens (2004)
suggests is connectivism. According to Siemens (2004) connectivism is “a learning theory for the digital age.” Siemens (2004) also suggested connectivism has several main principles. However, it could be suggested the main principle behind Siemens (2004) connectivism theory is that “learning and knowledge rests in diversity of opinions.” This is applicable to the Mobile Phone Wiki because every student will have differing opinions and experiences when it comes to the use of mobile phones in classrooms. This activity also reflects Siemens (2004) idea that “decisions are based on rapidly altering foundations.” This is applicable to the activity because opinions and ideas regarding mobile phones used in classrooms are continuingly being altered. It could be suggested any eLearning activity is reflective of connectivism because it requires the presenting of information to students and/or colleagues in the right context to be classed as a learning activity (Siemens, 2004).
How does an activity like this contribute to learning?
An interactive activity like the Mobile Phone Wiki can contribute significantly to student learning and understanding of topics raised in the classroom through interaction and engagement. The activity also encourages high order thinking because students are completely engaged in the learning activity. They also read and respond to other posts which encourages further analysis and evaluation of information which is provided. An activity such as the Mobile Phone Wiki is reflective of the principles within Bloom’s Digital Taxonomy.
The scaffold for this activity supported the collection of a range of perspectives by making the activity an essential component of this course. This allowed all students to present their opinions whilst engaging and learning from others.
Benefits and Drawbacks of Wikis
Personal Reflection
I have completed an activity which asked me to analyse whether or not mobile phones have a place in the classroom. The concept of implementing ICTs into my learning design is still taking some getting used to. When I graduated from high school in 2000, the internet was still a rather innovative ICT tool. I can remember it still being easier to attend the library rather than search fruitlessly for hours on end for a specific topic. How things have changed! The instant I wish to know something I go straight to google! When I was at school we relied on World Book Encyclopedia - which I still occasionally consult if I'm after information about past events. In my opinion the concept of having mobile phones in schools largely scares me with reports of bullying and intimidation seemingly becoming more frequent. It is a controversial question and I am sure there are many and varied opinions regarding this issue. Potentially they could be used for collaboratively learning in some instances however, mobile phones would have to be very closely monitored to ensure they are used for the correct purposes. Below are my responses to the "Negative" and "Intuitive" categories within this activity.
NEGATIVE:
The use of mobile phones in the classroom can lead to extreme distraction not to mention it could become a safety issue. Bullying at school could be bad enough 10 years ago when a simple note could be passed around a classroom and then binned when it was no longer required. Today, with the press of a button (whilst attending class) messages can be forwarded to other mobile phones not to mention immediately uploaded and distributed virally and I think sometimes children forget these images etc are there forever. Furthermore, I think mobile phones in classrooms require a mature and responsible mind. I think all schools should have policies in place to prevent students taking their mobile phones to class. If research needs to be done whilst in class – generally classrooms have at least one computer which could be used for research purposes. I think as teachers we have a duty of care to ensure mobile phones aren’t used for negative purposes within the classroom. I think the negatives outweigh the positives when it comes to the application of mobile phone use within a classroom. I think they are a distraction and it is doubtful they wouldn’t be used for texting which is not related to the content which is being administered in class.
INTUITIVE:
It could be suggested there are some benefits to using mobile phones in classrooms. For instance smart phones allow for access to the internet which could be used for class research and collaborative learning through group activities. Mobile phones could also be used for class activities with for games which could be complimentary to student learning. Mobile phones generally have functions such as timers and calculators so these could also be used for collaborative learning. If mobile phone use is closely monitored, they could be classed as a beneficial ICT to be implemented into our future learning designs.
REFERENCES:
Churches, A (2008). Bloom’s Digital Taxonomy. Retrieved from http://montgomeryschoolsmd.org/uploadedFiles/departments/techtraining/homepage/BloomDigitalTaxonomy2001.pdf
Education Queensland Risk Management Policy. Available at: http://education.qld.gov.au/web/schools/riskman.html
Lim, J. (2010) An Exploration of Learning Theory. 1 (1). Retrieved from http://www.janinelim.com/leadportfolio/pdfs/1c_Hiii-LearningTheoryRGPresentation.pdf
Mergel , B (1998). Instructional Design and Learning Theory. Retrieved from http://www.usask.ca/education/coursework/802papers/mergel/mergel.pdf
Siemens, G. (2005). Connectivism: A learning theory for the digital age. International Journal of Instructional Technology and Distance Learning, 2(1). Retrieved from http://www.itdl.org/Journal/Jan_05/article01.htm
University of Melbourne. Collaborative Learning. Retrieved from http://cms.unimelb.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/470868/Study-CollabLearning-Flyer.pdf
Vygotsky, L.S. (1978). Mind in Society. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard
No comments:
Post a Comment